The Legendary H.L. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5 Fly Rod: A Must-Have for Fly Fishing Enthusiasts
Fly fishing is more than just a sport—it’s an art form, and the right rod can make all the difference. Among the most revered names in fly fishing history is H.L. Leonard, a brand synonymous with craftsmanship, precision, and tradition. The CATSKILL 39.5 Fly Rod stands as a testament to this legacy, offering anglers an unparalleled blend of performance and heritage. Whether you’re chasing wild trout in mountain streams or casting for bass in tranquil lakes, this rod delivers an experience that modern graphite rods simply can’t replicate.
In this guide, we’ll explore the different types of H.L. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5 rods, how to choose the best one for your needs, our top five recommendations, key buying considerations, and answers to common questions.
—
Types of H.L. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5 Fly Rods
The CATSKILL 39.5 comes in several variations, primarily distinguished by:
– Action: Slow to medium action, offering a classic, smooth casting stroke.
– Material: Traditionally made from split bamboo (Tonkin cane), known for its flexibility and responsiveness.
– Line Weight: Typically designed for 4-5 weight lines, making it ideal for delicate presentations.
– Vintage vs. Modern Reproductions: Original Leonard rods are highly collectible, while some modern makers produce faithful reproductions.
—
How to Choose the Best H.L. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5 Fly Rod
When selecting your CATSKILL 39.5, consider:
✔ Intended Use – Small streams, dry flies, or light nymphing? This rod excels in delicate presentations.
✔ Casting Style – Prefers a slower, more deliberate stroke? Bamboo rods like this reward finesse.
✔ Budget – Vintage Leonard rods can be expensive; reproductions offer a more affordable entry point.
✔ Condition (if buying vintage) – Check for cracks, loose ferrules, or refinishing work.
—
Top 5 H.L. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5 Fly Rod Recommendations
1. Original H.L. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5 (Vintage)
– Highlights: Handcrafted split bamboo, legendary craftsmanship.
– Pros:
– Unmatched historical value and collectibility.
– Smooth, slow action perfect for dry fly fishing.
– Exquisite aesthetics with traditional wraps and varnish.
– Cons:
– Expensive and rare (often $2,000+).
– Requires careful maintenance.
– Best For: Collectors and purists who appreciate vintage tackle.
2. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5 Replica by Artisan Bamboo Rodmakers
– Highlights: Faithful reproduction using original techniques.
– Pros:
– More affordable than vintage originals.
– Handmade with high-quality Tonkin cane.
– Maintains the classic Leonard feel.
– Cons:
– Limited availability.
– Best For: Anglers who want the Leonard experience without vintage prices.
3. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5 (4-Weight)
– Highlights: Ideal for small-stream trout fishing.
– Pros:
– Exceptional sensitivity for delicate presentations.
– Lightweight and balanced.
– Cons:
– Not ideal for windy conditions.
– Best For: Dry fly purists and small-water anglers.
4. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5 (5-Weight)
– Highlights: Slightly more versatile for larger flies.
– Pros:
– Handles small streamers and nymphs better than the 4-weight.
– Still maintains a smooth, traditional action.
– Cons:
– Less specialized for ultra-fine dry fly work.
– Best For: Anglers who want a bit more versatility.
5. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5 (Restored Vintage Rod)
– Highlights: Professionally refurbished vintage rod.
– Pros:
– Combines authenticity with usability.
– Often more affordable than mint-condition originals.
– Cons:
– May have slight cosmetic imperfections.
– Best For: Those who want a functional vintage rod without paying top dollar.
—
Buying Considerations for the H.L. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5
– Authenticity: Verify provenance if buying vintage.
– Condition: Inspect for damage, especially in the cane and ferrules.
– Price: Expect to pay a premium for original Leonard rods.
– Maintenance: Bamboo rods require proper storage (cool, dry place) and occasional varnish touch-ups.
—
FAQ: Common Questions About the H.L. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5
Q1: Is the CATSKILL 39.5 suitable for beginners?
A: While it’s a fantastic rod, bamboo rods require a refined casting stroke. Beginners might prefer graphite for ease of use.
Q2: How do I maintain a bamboo fly rod?
A: Store it in a dry, temperature-controlled space, avoid excessive moisture, and occasionally apply rod wax.
Q3: Can I use modern fly lines with this rod?
A: Yes, but a DT (double taper) or silk line best complements its action.
Q4: Are modern reproductions as good as vintage Leonards?
A: Some are very close, but original Leonards have unmatched historical value.
Q5: What’s the best reel pairing for this rod?
A: A lightweight Hardy or Peerless reel balances well for classic aesthetics and performance.
—
Final Thoughts & Where to Buy
The H.L. Leonard CATSKILL 39.5 is more than just a fly rod—it’s a piece of angling history. Whether you’re a collector, a traditionalist, or simply someone who appreciates the finest craftsmanship, this rod belongs in your collection.
Ready to own a legend? Check reputable dealers like:
– Classic Fly Fisherman
– Lang’s Auction (for vintage models)
– Artisan bamboo rodmakers (for reproductions).
Cast with history—tight lines! 🎣