Vintage 1960’s DH Thompson Fly Tying Vice Elgin Illinois
Francis Haines 
# **Kylebooker Vintage 1960’s DH Thompson Fly Tying Vice Elgin Illinois: Is It Worth the Investment?**
For fly fishing enthusiasts, having a reliable and high-quality fly tying vice is essential. The **Kylebooker Vintage 1960’s DH Thompson Fly Tying Vice Elgin Illinois** is a classic piece that has garnered attention among anglers and collectors alike. But how does it perform in terms of functionality, durability, and overall value for money? In this review, we’ll explore whether this vintage vice is a worthwhile investment for modern fly tiers.
## **Historical Significance and Build Quality**
The **DH Thompson Fly Tying Vice** was originally manufactured in Elgin, Illinois, during the mid-20th century. Known for their sturdy construction, these vices were built to last. The **Kylebooker Vintage 1960’s model** retains the original craftsmanship, featuring a heavy-duty steel frame and a finely machined rotary mechanism. Unlike many modern plastic or lightweight aluminum vices, this one has a solid, old-school feel that many anglers appreciate.
One of the standout features is its **all-metal construction**, which ensures longevity. The jaws are precision-engineered to hold hooks securely without damaging them, making it suitable for tying delicate dry flies as well as larger streamers. The rotary function, though not as smooth as some high-end contemporary models, still performs well for most tying needs.
## **Performance and Usability**
While vintage equipment often comes with charm, it must also meet modern expectations. The **DH Thompson vice** excels in several areas:
1. **Hook Retention & Adjustability** – The jaws are strong and can accommodate a wide range of hook sizes, from tiny #24 midges to larger saltwater hooks. The adjustment knob allows for quick tightening and loosening, though it may require occasional lubrication for optimal performance.
2. **Rotary Functionality** – Unlike fixed vices, this model allows for 360-degree rotation, which is helpful for inspecting flies from all angles and applying materials evenly. However, some users note that the rotary action is not as buttery smooth as newer models like the Renzetti or Regal vices.
3. **Stability & Weight** – The vice’s heavy base ensures stability while tying, reducing wobble during intricate work. This makes it a great option for those who prefer a stationary setup rather than a clamp-on style.
## **Price and Value for Money**
One of the biggest considerations when purchasing a vintage fly tying vice is **cost versus performance**. The **Kylebooker Vintage 1960’s DH Thompson** typically sells for **$150–$300**, depending on condition and rarity. Compared to modern rotary vices in the same price range (such as the Griffin Odyssey Spider or the Peak Rotary), this model offers **nostalgic appeal and solid durability** but may lack some modern conveniences like quick-release jaws or ultra-smooth rotation.
For collectors or anglers who appreciate **vintage fishing gear**, this vice is a fantastic addition. However, if you prioritize **cutting-edge functionality**, you might find better options in newer models.
## **Final Verdict: Should You Buy It?**
The **Kylebooker Vintage 1960’s DH Thompson Fly Tying Vice** is a **well-built, durable tool** that stands the test of time. Its **classic design, strong jaws, and rotary function** make it a solid choice for traditionalists and those who enjoy tying flies on a piece of fishing history.
However, if you’re looking for **ultra-modern precision and ease of use**, you might prefer investing in a newer vice. That said, if you can find this model in good condition at a reasonable price, it’s a **great buy for both practical use and collection purposes**.
### **Pros:**
✔️ Durable all-metal construction
✔️ Strong, adjustable jaws for various hook sizes
✔️ Stable, heavy base minimizes movement
✔️ Vintage appeal for collectors
### **Cons:**
❌ Rotary action not as smooth as modern vices
❌ May require occasional maintenance (lubrication)
❌ Pricier than some entry-level modern alternatives
In conclusion, if you value **heritage and craftsmanship**, the **Kylebooker Vintage 1960’s DH Thompson Fly Tying Vice** is a **worthy investment**. But if cutting-edge performance is your priority, you may want to explore newer models. Either way, this vice remains a **classic piece of fly fishing history**.
Would you consider adding it to your tying bench? Let us know in the comments! 🎣